{"id":"N-MACHINE-DISCOVERY","url":"https://chrishayuk.com/notebook/the-site-was-there-the-agent-never-saw-it","currentVersion":"1.1","publication":"published","scientificStatus":"SUPPORTED","versions":[{"version":"1.0","title":"The site was there. The agent never saw it.","abstract":"MACHINE-DISCOVERY-1 tested whether a useful web capability could enter a Codex agent's consideration set. None of six subjects given a generic need or the target's distinctive phrases reached LLM Wilds, while all three subjects given its domain navigated to the machine contract and returned the rotating value. Three generic subjects discovered and used other machine-facing providers. The result locates this target's failure before selection, in the search view available to the subjects, rather than in capability recognition or use.","authors":["Chris Hay"],"url":"https://chrishayuk.com/records/N-MACHINE-DISCOVERY/1.0","published":"2026-09-13","publication":"published","scientificStatus":"SUPPORTED","experiments":[{"id":"MACHINE-DISCOVERY-1","url":"/data/machines/discovery-1-results.md"}],"supersededBy":[],"hash":"0aed31d94b907c3466b8626890c4b7dd9070dc8ed8a60295dd66defd900453ee","algorithm":"sha256","revision":{"kind":"initial","summary":"Initial publication of MACHINE-DISCOVERY-1: nine audited subjects locate the target's failure in search exposure before selection."},"next":"https://chrishayuk.com/records/N-MACHINE-DISCOVERY/1.1","sources":[{"title":"MACHINE-DISCOVERY-1 / audited outcomes and source hashes","url":"/data/machines/discovery-1-evidence.json","note":"Read from chuk-experiments: experiment EXP-20260911-071906-00753, write-up v4, nine completed counted runs, two preserved killed launcher attempts and one cancelled pre-amendment queue item. Subject record and transcript hashes are included.","preserved":{"url":"/data/publications/sha256/9049125fe85b9f4e8a7af872c8d7693634095cbf9f3d751ce347a8dc33e6040b.json","sha256":"9049125fe85b9f4e8a7af872c8d7693634095cbf9f3d751ce347a8dc33e6040b","date":"2026-09-13"}},{"title":"The final results and funnel interpretation","url":"/data/machines/discovery-1-results.md","note":"Public copy of the final report registered in chuk-experiments as artifact 1440 at source commit be0daa2672653746f30798483a3939ff3c8c3386.","preserved":{"url":"/data/publications/sha256/4e936715531500a41c67b2c7150ff9a17040bb682810fe5d4974e51ce27f8c7a.md","sha256":"4e936715531500a41c67b2c7150ff9a17040bb682810fe5d4974e51ce27f8c7a","date":"2026-09-13"}},{"title":"The frozen protocol and post-freeze population amendment","url":"/data/machines/discovery-1-protocol.md","note":"The design was frozen before any subject. The user then replaced the unavailable Claude population with fresh Codex processes before subject 01; arms, order, values, target, prompts and coding stayed fixed.","preserved":{"url":"/data/publications/sha256/b0e178e81cf60d0842ec84ee90c981f87f053eda6564c78267066b9e422876b3.md","sha256":"b0e178e81cf60d0842ec84ee90c981f87f053eda6564c78267066b9e422876b3","date":"2026-09-13"}}],"manuscript":"https://chrishayuk.com/api/record/N-MACHINE-DISCOVERY?version=1.0","citations":"https://chrishayuk.com/api/citations/N-MACHINE-DISCOVERY?version=1.0"},{"version":"1.1","title":"The site was there. The agent never saw it.","abstract":"MACHINE-DISCOVERY-1 tested whether a useful web capability could enter a Codex agent's consideration set. None of six subjects given a generic need or the target's distinctive phrases reached LLM Wilds, while all three subjects given its domain navigated to the machine contract and returned the rotating value. Three generic subjects discovered and used other machine-facing providers. The result locates this target's failure before selection, in the search view available to the subjects, rather than in capability recognition or use.","authors":["Chris Hay"],"url":"https://chrishayuk.com/records/N-MACHINE-DISCOVERY/1.1","published":"2026-09-13","revised":"2026-09-13","publication":"published","scientificStatus":"SUPPORTED","experiments":[{"id":"MACHINE-DISCOVERY-1","url":"/data/machines/discovery-1-results.md"}],"supersededBy":[],"hash":"74bf687605cd46a97bff53bfba9cae339185555a17b81a97801cfdbac056335d","algorithm":"sha256","revision":{"kind":"clarification","summary":"Rewrote the reading sequence and visual explanations; clarified exposure, crawler attribution and the untested retrieval counterfactual without changing recorded outcomes.","previous":"1.0"},"previous":"https://chrishayuk.com/records/N-MACHINE-DISCOVERY/1.0","sources":[{"title":"MACHINE-DISCOVERY-1 / audited outcomes and source hashes","url":"/data/machines/discovery-1-evidence.json","note":"Read from chuk-experiments: experiment EXP-20260911-071906-00753, write-up v4, nine completed counted runs, two preserved killed launcher attempts and one cancelled pre-amendment queue item. Subject record and transcript hashes are included.","preserved":{"url":"/data/publications/sha256/9049125fe85b9f4e8a7af872c8d7693634095cbf9f3d751ce347a8dc33e6040b.json","sha256":"9049125fe85b9f4e8a7af872c8d7693634095cbf9f3d751ce347a8dc33e6040b","date":"2026-09-13"}},{"title":"The final results and funnel interpretation","url":"/data/machines/discovery-1-results.md","note":"Public copy of the final report registered in chuk-experiments as artifact 1440 at source commit be0daa2672653746f30798483a3939ff3c8c3386.","preserved":{"url":"/data/publications/sha256/4e936715531500a41c67b2c7150ff9a17040bb682810fe5d4974e51ce27f8c7a.md","sha256":"4e936715531500a41c67b2c7150ff9a17040bb682810fe5d4974e51ce27f8c7a","date":"2026-09-13"}},{"title":"The frozen protocol and post-freeze population amendment","url":"/data/machines/discovery-1-protocol.md","note":"The design was frozen before any subject. The user then replaced the unavailable Claude population with fresh Codex processes before subject 01; arms, order, values, target, prompts and coding stayed fixed.","preserved":{"url":"/data/publications/sha256/b0e178e81cf60d0842ec84ee90c981f87f053eda6564c78267066b9e422876b3.md","sha256":"b0e178e81cf60d0842ec84ee90c981f87f053eda6564c78267066b9e422876b3","date":"2026-09-13"}}],"manuscript":"https://chrishayuk.com/api/record/N-MACHINE-DISCOVERY?version=1.1","citations":"https://chrishayuk.com/api/citations/N-MACHINE-DISCOVERY?version=1.1"}]}